Pages

Solid Bible Teachers Review "The Shack"

Things You Should Consider About "The Shack" Theology - Solid Bible Teachers Review It

Having read scores of reviews of The Shack by Christian teachers, the consensus seems to be this: The book has some good Biblical elements mixed with a great deal of Biblical error. 


The Shack Author, Wm Paul Young, has released a book called "Lies People Believe" which explains his beliefs, many of which contradict Scripture. His misrepresentations of God in The Shack clearly represent his false beliefs in the character of God and the message of the gospel.

It's critically important that Christians use discernment with popular teachings and let God's Word judge men's words (Romans 16:17; Acts 17:11; Colossians 2:8; 1 Peter 5:8; 2 Timothy 4:3-4; 1 John 4:1).

Below are excerpts of longer articles written by solid Bible teachers. 

I hope these will whet your appetite to read some of the longer articles, and I pray they will help you discern the message of The Shack.

Note that the Coulter excerpt offers both pros and cons as do many of the other articles in full length.

The Shack: Helpful or Heretical
Norman Geisler

"THE SHACK may do well for many in engaging the current culture, but not without compromising Christian truth. The book may be psychologically helpful to many who read it, but it is doctrinally harmful to all who are exposed to it. It has a false understanding of God, the Trinity, the person and work of Christ, the nature of man, the institution of the family and marriage, and the nature of the Gospel. For those not trained in orthodox Christian doctrine, this book is very dangerous. It promises good news for the suffering but undermines the only Good News (the Gospel) about Christ suffering for us. In the final analysis it is only truth that is truly liberating. Jesus said, “You shall know the truth and the truth shall set you free” (John 8:32). A lie may make one feel better, but only until he discovers the truth."

How the Shack Distorts Our View of God
Jack Wellman

“Even though The Shack is fiction, I believe it is dangerous, particularly for new Christians, because they don’t have enough knowledge of the Bible and of God, and so they might confuse these fictional characters with the way God really is…In the author’s fictional view, Jesus’ sacrifice allows Christians and non-Christians to spend eternity with God, in what is deemed, Universal Reconciliation. In other words, everybody goes to heaven, not just followers of Jesus, and some in this camp even include the devil and his demons.”

Exploring the Shack
Paul Coulter

Leading Bible Teachers review the dangerous theology of The Shack. Powerful Warnings.

The Shack is firmly orthodox in a number of important respects:

“• It portrays a personal God who is Creator of all things and who is actively involved in His creation and especially in the lives of people.
• It places Christ at the centre of God’s historical purposes.
• It emphasises the need for a personal relationship with God based on His grace rather than a legalistic religion of works righteousness or a fearful belief in a God who must be appeased.
On the other hand, the book has several theological weaknesses:
• Its portrayal of the trinity is at best confused and at worst unbiblical.
• It undermines the concept of authority and belittles the importance of Scripture.
• It seems to belittle the importance of the local church in God’s purposes.
• It calls into question the idea that belief in certain objective truths is important in Christian faith.
• It is imbalanced in its depiction of God’s character, emphasising His love at the expense of His holiness.
• It is soft on human sin and seems to leave no room for the wrath of God or for judgement.
• It fails to present the cross as the sole basis for redemption or to explain how the cross could have achieved salvation.
• It is unclear about whether or not all people will ultimately be saved.
These are not minor, peripheral issues in theology.

The Shack — The Missing Art of Evangelical Discernment
Albert Mohler

“In evaluating the book, it must be kept in mind that The Shack is a work of fiction. But it is also a sustained theological argument…the really troubling fact is that so many readers are drawn to the theological message of the book, and fail to see how it conflicts with the Bible at so many crucial points. All this reveals a disastrous failure of evangelical discernment…The answer is not to ban The Shack… We need not fear books — we must be ready to answer them…The Shack is a wake-up call for evangelical Christianity….The popularity of this book among evangelicals can only be explained by a lack of basic theological knowledge among us — a failure even to understand the Gospel of Christ. The tragedy that evangelicals have lost the art of biblical discernment must be traced to a disastrous loss of biblical knowledge. Discernment cannot survive without doctrine.

The Shack
Got Questions.org

“Young's intentions are good. He wants to introduce readers to a loving God who was willing to sacrifice his own Son to save us from our sins. But all heresies begin with misconstruing the nature of God. From Jehovah's Witnesses to Mormonism to even Islam, they all get it wrong when it comes to understanding the God of Scripture. Young joins their company. Part of the problem arises because his story is confused and inconsistent. He doesn’t set out to mislead, but he himself is misled, either by himself or others.

Critique of the Shack
Patrick Zukeran

Throughout his book Young emphasizes the relational aspect of our walk with God and downplays the need for proper doctrinal beliefs about God... An essential part of growing a deep intimate relationship with God involves the learning of Biblical and doctrinal truths about God. The Apostle Paul refers to this in Ephesians 4:13 when he says, “until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ...One cannot take lightly erroneous teachings on the nature of God and salvation.”

What Does The Shack Really Teach?
Tim Challis

"In Lies We Believe About God [Paul Young's recently released non-fiction book], we see Paul Young apart from the subjectivity of narrative. And as he proclaims what he denies and affirms, he outs himself as beyond the bounds of Christian orthodoxy. This book is a credo for false teaching, for full-out heresy. I do not say this lightly, I do not say it gleefully, but I do say it confidently. Christian booksellers should be utterly ashamed to sell this book or any other by its author. Christians should not subject themselves to his teaching or promote his works, for he despises sound doctrine that leads to salvation and advocates false doctrine that will only ever lead away from God."

More articles:
How Should a Christian Think About the Shack?
Hank Hanegraaff

If you'd like solid Biblical truth, check out these resources:

https://www.amazon.com/Wisdom-Life-Devotional-One-Minute-Reflections/dp/1087775760

I encourage you to check out the Wisdom for Life Devotional. It contains 100 one-minute devotions to challenge, encourage, instruct, and inspire your love for God's Word: Wisdom for Life. Read the story behind Wisdom for Life HERE. And find out about the two free Bible studies with purchase HERE. You can read the first 4 devotions in the book by clicking "look inside" on Lifeway or Amazon.
 
I also encourage you to sign up for a free subscription to Bible Love Notes and get a free e-booklet. Find out more HERE.


Leading Bible Teachers review the dangerous theology of The Shack. Powerful Warnings.



1 comment:

  1. I think it is fair to say that a person struggling with death that has little knowledge could come to desire more understanding. And when one does this, they learn while maturing as a Christian the right teachings. Anyone reading the Bible with little or no knowledge about God's word could misunderstand and mist interpret as well. When one has the Holy Spirit, reading and praying before and during studying the Bible allows God to help the person learn and grow. It's Divine!

    ReplyDelete