Wednesday

CAPTCHA

Word verification (CAPTCHA) is used by the majority of bloggers to screen comments. Unfortunately, it operates as the LETTER OF THE LAW (pun intended), not the spirit of the law. It’s meant to prohibit bad users, but ends up prohibiting good users as well.

Purpose of Word Verification: CAPTCHA is designed to prevent automated spam—to verify that your user is a human being, not a computer. Blogspot now uses a double word CAPTCHA which I find challenging at times… "Is that an ‘n’ or an ‘r’?”

The Drawbacks of Word Verification. It:
  • can be difficult to read--impossible for the seeing-impaired
  • can add 1-2 steps to the commenting process
  • can prevent people from commenting
  • does nothing to prevent rude or vulgar human comments
  • doesn't stop all programs created by spammers anyway!

Should You Use CAPTCHA?
Obviously, you should pray about it, but here's my suggestions:
  • If you’re moderating your comments, why not turn it off and make it easier for people to make comments on your posts?
  • If you’ve had problems with machine-generated spam comments, then maybe you should use it. But remember it won't help with offensive human comments. And make sure that screening out bad users is worth losing some good users.
  • I don't moderate comments, but I still don't use CAPTCHA. 
On my two sites, I cut my spam by 99% by simply prohibiting anonymous comments.  


I don’t know about you, but I am blessed by comments, and I don’t want to dissuade people from leaving them. Why not leave me one now and let me know your experience with spammers, CAPTCHA, and comments. I'm sure there are things I could learn from you.

P.S. = How to disable CAPTCHA on Blogspot:
Go to Design, then Settings, then Posts and Comments, then click "no" beside "Show Word Verification?"

P.S.S. = Spam on your page view stats
I admit computer-generated spam is annoying. Even though I don't get spam comments, I get a lot of computer-generated page views a month, usually from sites in Russia (somehow they make illegal money from this). Unfortunately, this is common and the best thing to do is ignore it or report it to Blogspot/Google. You get more accurate stats on Google Analytics.

Caution: Make sure you never check out a suspicious url while viewing your stats. When spammers get visits from your site, they tend to send more spam your way. If you want to check out a url, copy and paste it into a separate browser first.

12 comments:

  1. I agree. The CAPTCHA feature is a pain. I love just writing something to another blogger and moving on. Think of all the extra time I could be looking around your blog too! Don't slow me down.

    www.funkiplanet.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Some bloggers refuse to make comments where CAPTCHA is enabled, so it probably turns away more comments than most folks realize.

      Delete
  2. I HATE HATE HATE Capthcha. I actually realized today that it was still turned on, on one of my blogs. Since installing intense debate on my own blog, I haven't had any problems with spammers, ID does a pretty good job of stopping spam.

    Intense debate also has a feature where you can turn off moderation on posts, except the ones that have certain key words. So I went through and added every vulgarity to my list I could think of and words that are considered "hot button issues" so if anyone does make a comment I get to see those first before their posted (does that make sense) I really like the feature it allows me to turn off comment moderation and stops vulgar and spam posts just the same.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for sharing this info about Intense debate...I'm not familiar with how it works.

      Delete
  3. Good tip about not clicking the link from your site! Also, I wholeheartedly agree about captcha! It's really frustrating to take the time to leave a thoughtful, encouraging comment, and then have to be prompted (in a new screen) to enter the code, which may or may not be correct on the first try. Really frustrating for readers who want to leave a comment and have slow internet.

    It's even more frustrating when I see that comment moderation is enabled, which means that spam comments wouldn't be posted directly to the blog anyway, and since the majority of my blogging circle is made up of Christian mommy blogs, they are almost ALL moderated.

    Thanks for addressing this!

    I would also like to add that I appreciate it when people allow comments from name/url, since I have a self-hosted wordpress blog, and openID, though I tried to install it, doesn't work properly, so I have no way to leave a comment except to go through the process of signing into my old wordpress account.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for these additional thoughts, Crystal.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with everything you have said here. Amen!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yep, Captcha is a pain. Too hard to read the letters!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Joe, I agree that it is hard reading the letters. I have once tried to enter the captcha words 3 times in a row and finally gave up. Some are hard and some are readable, you just are taking a chance. And trying to do the handicap way is hard to get used to also.

      Delete
  7. My blog is a new blog. I have been blogging for about a month and got just over 5,000 page views my first month. My first week of blogging an experienced blogger told me I would do better if I removed the captcha option. I did so (left the moderation of the comments) and I get a LOT of comments now compared to hardly any. How long did it take you to build up so many page views? Any hints or tips for me? I am doing a lot of weekly link ups and Google adwords.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melody, you're doing great! I definitely didn't have 5000 page views my first month...more like 500. You'll build as people get acquainted with your blog, and with such a good start, you'll probably pass me up in a few months! Thanks also for confirming that disabling the CAPTCHA can increase comments.

      Delete
  8. I just put CAPTCHA on tonight before finding your site :P and will take it off!! I strongly dislike using this feature as it makes me feel like I have a learning disability!! I get those letters wrong all the time!! lol

    Thanks so much!!

    ReplyDelete

All Scripture references NIV unless otherwise noted.